Menu

Review: DESIRE UNDER THE ELMS at Almeida Theatre

Stuart King 18 November, 2026, 00:15

Eugene O’Neill’s ‘farming and infanticide’ melodrama which he finished in the summer of 1924, is deemed by some literary scholars to rank with his masterworks “Long Day’s Journey into Night” and “The Iceman Cometh”. Given the symbolic parallels with Greek tragedy, it is probably closer to “Mourning Becomes Electra”. Whatever the case, it is something of a tough watch.

Desire Under the Elms at Almeida TheatreDesire Under the Elms at Almeida Theatre. Photo by Marc Brenner

Helming the production for the Almeida, Ebenezer Bamgboye has made an omelet, but hasn’t necessarily cracked all the eggs to do so. The result is at best texturally uneven and occasionally unpalatable.

Younger brother Eben (Zackary Momoh) seeks to buy-out his older half-siblings Peter and Simeon (Thomas Coombes and Jamie Beamish) from their share in the family farmstead. He intends to honour his recently departed mother by remaining in the Deep South while they bid to make their fortunes in the California gold rush. No sooner have the brothers left, when father Ephraim (Antony Byrne) who left two months before, returns with a much younger new wife Abbie (Kelly Gough). Feathers are ruffled and this being O’Neill, hormones rage, although in this production they simmer and stew, rather than come to the boil.

Themes of incestuous desire and infanticide inveigle their way into proceedings as the young wife and son slough-off their inconvenient familial nomenclature and embark on a doomed and lust-laden adventure under the roof and sometimes under the stars, but always under the nose of Ephraim. The resultant baby initially confirms their commitment and secret love but later proves a wedge which drives them apart due to male insecurity, pride and foolishness. As so often happens in such tragic circumstances, the woman at the centre of the story is compelled to make a heartbreaking decision and sacrifice, yet ultimately loses everything anyway.

While the writing has absorbed some modernising of the dialogue and changes to period, location, and race emphasis, it fails to ever gather or maintain sufficient momentum to be compelling. Indeed the 2 hour and 40 minutes running time (including interval) vastly outstays its welcome. Interesting elements incorporated here, include three musical spirits who roam in and out of scenes — apparitions who have influence and exert some control, without us ever fully comprehending how or why. All credit to the team for mounting a rarely performed O’Neill, but frankly despite the creditable effort and commitment, this felt like a misguided venture and exceedingly unlikely seasonal fayre.

DESIRE UNDER THE ELMS continues at the Almeida until 23rd December.

Latest News