A complete guide to choosing the best theatre show for you
Shehrazade Zafar-Arif
20 November, 2026, 15:33
Theatre lovers in London face a unique problem - we’re spoiled for choice! There are so many fantastic shows playing in the city that sometimes you just can’t decide what to watch. In this guide, we’ve broken down all your different options to help you figure out what kind of show you’d most enjoy, depending on your preferences, expectations, and the kind of experience you want to have.

Summary
- Play or musical, comedy or tragedy - it entirely depends on what you're hoping to get out of your theatre experience.
- Within musicals, you can choose between jukebox musicals and book musicals.
- Choose between an original, adaptation, or revival, and decide whether you want something traditional or more immersive.
- And make sure you don't sleep on fringe theatre!
Play or musical?
The million dollar question! Plays rely on spoken dialogue and acting, while musicals incorporate songs, music, and dance numbers into their dialogue - or are sometimes even completely sung-through, like Jesus Christ Superstar.
It’s entirely a matter of personal taste. Some people find musicals cheesy, while others may get bored with a long play that isn’t broken up by musical numbers. If you’re a musically inclined person, then you’re likely to enjoy a show like Les Miserables where music is woven into the storytelling. But if you’re a more story or plot-driven person, then you might prefer to lose yourself in a play like The Mousetrap without the distraction of musical numbers.
Book musical or jukebox musical?
A book musical features original songs written specifically for the show, while a jukebox musical utilises pre-existing, usually well-known songs. If the idea of hearing your favourite songs woven into a story appeals to you, then you may want to opt for a jukebox musical. Check out Moulin Rouge! The Musical for thrilling medleys and mashups of modern pop songs, or Mamma Mia! if you’re an ABBA fan. But if you’re keen to fall in love with a brand new soundtrack of songs, then you’ll probably love Hadestown’s dreamy folk score or Hamilton’s catchy hiphop musical style.
Check out our complete guide to musicals for a more in-depth breakdown of the different types of musicals.
What would prefer a jukebox musical like Moulin Rouge! or a book musical like Hadestown?
Comedy or tragedy?
There’s a reason why the universal symbol of theatre is the comedy and tragedy masks. Of course, most shows can’t always be neatly slotted into either of two binaries, but it’s a helpful way to categorise them when you’re considering your options. The question is: what do you want to feel coming out of the theatre?
Perhaps you want something serious that explores real-world and often difficult issues, like The Lives of Others, or something that evokes strong feelings and gives you a cathartic release of emotion like Wild About You. Or perhaps you want something light-hearted and uplifting to help you escape from reality and leave you feeling hopeful like Paddington the Musical, or something farcical and silly that you can switch your mind off to enjoy without being made to think too much, like Christmas Carol Goes Wrong.
Adaptation, revival, or original?
A lot of the biggest shows in the West End are adaptations of popular films, like The Devil Wears Prada and Beetlejuice the Musical, or books, like The Humans or Ballet Shoes. For many of us, there’s a comfort in a familiar, predictable story and it’s a special thrill to see a favourite story come to life onstage, retold in a fresh or often unexpected way - just be warned, a stage adaptation won’t always be fully faithful to the original, so manage your expectations accordingly.
Is there such a thing as adaptation fatigue? We've unpacked this in our opinion piece about the West End's love affair with adaptations.
The great thing about the West End is that classic shows tend to make a comeback in the form of revivals after their original run has ended. This is a great way got you to experience a play or musical you know and love re-told in a fresh way, or see what all the hype is about with a popular show you may have not gotten the chance to watch before - whether it's a beloved piece of musical theatre like RENT and West Side Story, or a timeless bit of Shakespeare like Julius Caesar.
But maybe you want to enjoy a brand new original story and fall in love with characters you’ve never encountered before. That’s a great way to step out of your own comfort zone and encounter stories you may never have considered - like a tongue-in-cheek take on Abraham Lincoln’s wife in Oh, Mary! or a modern retelling of The Crucible in John Proctor is the Villain.
Would you prefer an original play like Oh, Mary! or an adaptation like The Devil Wears Prada?
Immersive or traditional?
If you’re an old-school theatre goer, you may be content to sit back in your seat, relax, and let the actors and story transport you to another world. But if you want a theatre experience that's more active and interactive, then you might want to check out an immersive show like Pirates of the Caribbean: The Immersive Adventure, which lets you wander through the world of the popular film, or a show with interactive elements, like The Traitors - Acts of Betrayal, where the audience gets to participate in what direction the story goes.
West End or fringe?
When most people think of London theatre, their mind immediately jumps to the West End, but there’s plenty of excellent theatre to be found if you wander further afield.
West End shows often include big budgets, star-studded casts, and large-scale productions hosted in large, commercial theatres. If you're looking for spectacle and blockbuster quality, or keen to tick a big-name show like Stranger Things: The First Shadow off your list, the West End is your best bet. But you may also fall in love with the smaller, independent productions hosted in intimate venues. It's a great way to experience shows you might not have otherwise gotten to see (usually at a much cheaper price!) and support up and coming artists. Fringe theatre also tends to be more experimental and boundary-pushing, like the award-winning stand-up show Feeling Afraid As If Something Terrible is Going to Happen - great for those who enjoy the unexpected or surprising.
If you're interested in fringe theatre, check out our list of the best of Edinburgh Fringe.
Know Your Audience
There’s other questions to consider when you’re picking a show. A big one is who you’re going with. If you’re going with children, you’ll want to opt for a family-friendly show, like The Snowman. If you’re going on a date, then you may want something more romantic, like One Day. If you’re going with a group of friends, like on a girls’ night, then you may want something fun and universally appealing, like SIX. And if you’re going alone, then the choice is entirely yours!
For more inspiration, check out our Black Friday sale to get some of the best deals and offers on the hottest shows.
Latest News
A complete guide to choosing the best theatre show for you
20 November 2026 at 15:33
THE POPINJAY CAVALIER announces West End cast
20 November 2026 at 11:14
Review: EUROTRASH at Young Vic
20 November 2026 at 00:17
Production images released for ONE DAY THE MUSICAL
19 November 2026 at 13:38